Enterprise Adoption3 min read

AI Only Pays Off When Another Cost Disappears

By , Senior AI ConsultantPublished

AI saves hours, but a saving counts only when a contractor, a software tool or a markdown leaves the budget, as one renewal at Snowflake shows.

AI suppliers want you to use more AI, and you want your costs to fall. Some of them have now noticed that these two aims pull apart at renewal time, and a few are advising customers to buy less, because a finance team that sees only more activity will eventually stop paying.

Saved time is not saved money

Picture a small distributor whose clerk spends 10 hours a week answering supplier emails. An AI assistant takes over most of it. That is about 520 hours a year, a quarter of a full-time job. But the clerk is paid the same as before, so the books show nothing. The saving turns into money in only two ways: the clerk takes over work that used to cost overtime or an agency, or the agency contract ends. Hours saved are the first half of the argument, and the cancelled cost is the second.

Companies are stuck on the first half. 80% of people using AI say it makes them more productive, yet only 37% report that it has added anything to their company's profit, about the same share as a year earlier. People feel faster, and the accounts do not move, because the freed hours are scattered across many people and none of them removes a cost.

This is the same test we described in AI pays off when it moves one number finance already tracks, and the Snowflake renewal shows the other side of it: the customer's finance team could not book two weeks of analyst time, but it could book two retired software tools.

Factories made this mistake with electricity

Electric light was on sale by 1879. When factories first bought electric motors, they often pulled out the steam engine and put a motor in its place. The machines stayed where they were, because the old layout had them clustered around the engine. Productivity barely improved. The gains came when factories were rebuilt as single-floor lines, with materials moving from one machine to the next, and in the 1920s US manufacturing productivity grew more than 5% a year.

An AI assistant placed inside an unchanged process is the new motor in the old engine's spot. The money shows up when the process itself changes: the reconciliation that no longer needs a team, the support queue that no longer needs an outside agency. Those changes take months, so the useful interim signal is something finance already counts, such as how many proposals reach a short list, not how many proposals the AI wrote.

Your suppliers face the same test, and that is useful to you

The same logic runs against the AI seller. The Indian IT services company Infosys grew its AI revenue 29% in one quarter, to 10.5% of sales, and still lowered its yearly growth outlook to 1%-2%, with clients pushing for lower prices. When AI lets a client buy the same service for less, the client's saving is the supplier's lost contract.

If you buy work from an agency, an IT firm or a bookkeeper, assume they can now do it faster, and ask for the price to follow. Some will say yes, and they are the ones to keep.

Agree what "done" means before you pay

Two other habits from this news are easy to copy. First, match the model to the job. In Snowflake's account of one financial services client, staff were running expensive top-tier models on routine support tickets and document extraction; moving those jobs to smaller models cut the cost by more than half with no loss in accuracy. If you use ChatGPT, Gemini or Claude for routine work, the cheapest model that does the job is the right one.

Second, define a finished job in writing. A closed support ticket is not a solved problem if the employee then spends 30 minutes fixing it alone. One vendor charges $1 to $3 only for work that leaves the employee able to do their job, and it does not count an access request as complete until the person can log in.

So before the next renewal, write down three things: the line on your books that should shrink, the date by which it should, and who decides whether a job counts as done. If the answer to the first is "nothing", you are paying for activity.

Share this

STAY INFORMED

Get AI intelligence like this delivered to your inbox.

Free forever · Unsubscribe anytime


You May Also Find Valuable